Doujinshi: A Complete Guide to Japanese Fan Publications

Doujinshi: A Complete Guide to Japanese Fan Publications

Inside self-published manga, circles and the world's largest comic fair.

Doujinshi are self-published manga, magazines and novels from Japan. The word is often translated as fanfiction, but that is too narrow: doujinshi can tell original stories, parody existing series or take completely different forms. This guide explains where the term comes from, how the scene works, what happens at Comic Market and how Japanese copyright practice treats these works.

Readers who only know the headline often mistake doujinshi for illegal copies. In fact they are a separate market with circles, fairs and decades of history. The key terms and connections are laid out below in an order that works without prior knowledge.

Anime characters holding up self-made booklets at a sales table
Contents 7

What does doujinshi mean?

The word doujinshi (同人誌) is short for doujin zasshi (同人雑誌). Doujin refers to people who share the same tastes, while zasshi means magazine. In practice it describes booklets and books published by the creators themselves, without a publisher or editorial board. That makes them similar to fanzines, but firmly tied to Japanese manga and anime culture. Readers who first want to sort out the differences between manga, manhwa and manhua will find a separate article on that topic.

The range is wide. A doujinshi can be a few loosely bound sheets, a five-page booklet or a magazine of more than 200 pages. Format, paper and binding vary just as much. In 2000, prices ranged from about 200 to 1,200 yen per copy. Because no editor interferes, creative freedom is high, and quality runs from simple photocopies to work that resembles professional publications.

Shelves packed with manga volumes in a bookstore

Original works and parody: 一次創作 and 二次創作

Doujinshi come in two basic forms. Original works are called ichiji sōsaku (一次創作); they tell their own stories, characters and worlds. Far more common are works based on existing series, known as niji sōsaku (二次創作). Characters from manga, anime or games are placed in new stories without official permission. During the 1980s the scene shifted decisively toward this derivative approach.

Many of these works are humorous or parodic, which is why Japanese fans use the term aniparo, a portmanteau of animation and parody. Others tell romantic or erotic stories between characters who never get together in the source material. That is precisely the appeal for many readers: doujinshi show what the official story does not.

Collage of several Dragon Ball characters, including Goku, Vegeta and Frieza

Who makes doujinshi? Doujinka and circles

Creators are called doujinka (同人家). Most are amateurs, often students or people with other jobs. They team up in circles (サークル, sākuru), which appear at fairs under a shared name. Some circles consist of a single person, called a kojin sākuru (個人サークル), or personal circle. Professional manga artists also take part in doujinshi in order to work outside publishing constraints. Many successful artists, in turn, started in the scene. Anyone who wants to start drawing can find tips for becoming a mangaka.

A hand with a mechanical pencil drawing manga figures over technical construction lines

Comiket and the fair circuit

Doujinshi are sold mainly at fairs. The largest is the Comic Market, or Comiket, held twice a year in Tokyo and considered the biggest comic fair in the world. Around 35,000 circles take part, and in peak years the event attracts hundreds of thousands of visitors. In December 2019 about 750,000 people attended; after the pandemic cancellations, the December 2021 edition drew around 110,000.

Comiket was founded in 1975 by students unhappy with the way the Nihon Manga Taikai was organised. The first event had only a few dozen circles and around 600 visitors. In the 1980s it became the central event of the emerging otaku culture and now takes place at the Big Sight venue in Odaiba. Many smaller sales events exist alongside it, such as Comic City, which focuses on works by and for women.

Crowds in a convention hall and sales tables covered in doujinshi at Comiket

In Japan, doujinshi can be found at stores such as Mandarake, K-BOOKS and Toranoana, as well as online and at flea markets. These shops buy second-hand copies and resell them, which gives many circles a second outlet.

Many doujinshi use characters owned by someone else. In Japan such works fall under shinkokuzai (親告罪), a category of offence that is prosecuted only if the rights holder files a complaint. As long as no complaint is made, creators are generally not prosecuted, and publishers rarely enforce their rights because the scene is seen as a training ground and promotion channel for the professional market.

In 2016 Prime Minister Shinzō Abe confirmed that position: doujinshi do not compete with the originals or damage rights holders, so the practice falls under shinkokuzai. That does not mean there are no rules. In 2013 the dōjin mark (同人マーク) was created, modelled on Creative Commons licences. Manga artist Ken Akamatsu was the first to use it in his series UQ Holder! to explicitly allow fan works.

Key categories and terms

Doujinshi aimed at female readers are called joseimuke (女性向け). A large share of them is BL or Yaoi, stories about love between male characters. Works for male readers are labelled danseimuke (男性向け), a category often reduced to hentai even though many titles are comedic or entirely non-erotic. Original stories are called sōsaku (創作), while anthologies collect works by several doujinka. One genre that was tested early in the doujinshi scene is mecha.

From English-language fanfiction culture come codes such as lemon for explicit sex scenes, lime for erotic but non-explicit content, orange for explicit scenes between women and citrus for romantic stories between women. These labels are not specifically Japanese, but they also appear in international doujinshi and fanfiction circles.

Purple-haired anime character reading a booklet while hiding under a blanket
Anime characters with startled expressions, matching the theme of fujoshi and yaoi

Known artists and circles

Several well-known manga artists started in the doujinshi scene. The group CLAMP, later known for Cardcaptor Sakura and xxxHolic, began as a doujinshi circle. Yun Kouga (Loveless, Earthian), Ken Akamatsu (Love Hina) and Kiyohiko Azuma (Azumanga Daioh, Yotsuba) also gained early experience with self-published works. The pioneer of modern manga, Osamu Tezuka, was not a doujinshi creator, but he remains a model for many fan artists.

Portrait of Osamu Tezuka next to a drawing of Astro Boy and other characters

The selection below lists well-known circles and their doujinka as recorded in fan databases. It is not complete, but it shows the breadth of the scene.

CircleDoujinka
Plastics echo (プラスチックエコー)Takaoka Nanaroku (高岡七六)
Jack in the BoxPokachi (ポカチ)
Shisinden (紫宸殿)Rinko Sakura (櫻林子) and Mizuki Tachibana (橘水樹)
PARSIFAL (パルシファル)Nikora Ichijou (一条ニコラ)
AIMAIME (曖昧me)Kouu Hiyoyo (紅雨ヒヨヨ)
mount10Nozarashi Bugyou (のざらし奉行)
Master and Pupil LOVERShiwo Honjoh (本城シヲ)
SugarCoco Satoh (さとうここ)
Kurukuru Girl (くるくる少女)Yuna Akiyama (秋山ゆな) and Rei Miyabi (雅れい)
Gekkou Touzoku (月光盗賊)Nobi Nobita (野火ノビタ)
Konjou Kumiai (根性組合)Yoko Fujitani (藤谷陽子)
Zuihouzakura (ずいほう桜)Rae Hasutsuki (蓮月らえ)
EdeDaichi Tachibana (たちばな大地)
Shouyuya (しょうゆ屋)Tsuki Ayumu (槻歩向)
Mirin Kankou Oukoku (みりん観光王国)Miyahara Tatsumi (宮原たつみ)
Atomic PunchMoyo (モヨ)
Nekogami-Dou (猫神堂)shima
Close-up of a manga face drawn in pencil on paper
A crowded sales table at a fair on the left, a stack of pencil sketches on the right

Doujinshi are therefore more than a niche hobby. They are a testing ground where new styles and genres appear long before the mass market picks them up. For many professionals they are a side channel, and for many amateurs the first step into the manga world. Anyone who wants to understand Japanese pop culture cannot ignore this self-organised publishing scene.

Sources and Useful Links

About the author

Kevin Henrique

Kevin Henrique has written about the Japanese language, culture, anime, games, and travel since founding Suki Desu in 2014. He first visited Japan in 2016.

Community

Comments

0 comments

There are no published comments in this language yet.

Send comment

Comment on this article

Loading security check...

Do not send links, embeds, or promotions. Comments are checked for spam and may be translated before they appear.