Sometimes I come across indirect comments asking whether I have lived in Japan, as if living in the country were a requirement to write about it. So I decided to address exactly this question: Do you need to live in Japan to understand the country?
Some people who live or have lived in Japan feel superior to others and act as if they know more than everyone else. The truth is that living in Japan does not mean a person has any knowledge about the country. I have written before about the superiority complex of some people of Japanese descent.
On my first trip to Japan, I met several Japanese people and asked various questions related to the topics I have written about over the years. From those questions, I came to the conclusion that even Japanese people do not know everything about their own country. Probably because most of them live in their comfort zone and only know what suits them.
Contents 4
Why you do not need to live in Japan to understand it
Do history teachers need to have lived through the events they teach? Do you realize that one of the most famous books about wealth came from a man who was born in a one-room cabin in rural Virginia? Napoleon Hill wrote the best-selling Think and Grow Rich, published in 1937.
It was after watching a video by Bruno Avila that I kept turning these thoughts over in my head, wanting to tell everyone that you do not need to live in Japan to know more than a Japanese person or someone who has lived there. Shall we look at another example that Bruno provided?
Imagine you want to buy an apartment. Normally, you would not ask for help from someone who has never bought one. You would turn to a good guide on real estate investments. What would you think if you discovered that the author of this guide has never bought a property in their life? And what if this author has interviewed the 20 most popular real estate investors in the world?
A person may have attended various colleges, worked in different places, and experienced a lot in Japan and elsewhere. This does not mean that they have more knowledge than you. They may even have more knowledge, but there is a good chance that you know many things they do not. Knowledge is infinite!
Can anyone know everything?
I think everyone knows that you do not need to experience something to know about it. Unfortunately, some people hastily claim that certain things can only be known through experience. I see this a lot in reactions to articles where I try to highlight some cultural or everyday aspect of life for foreigners in Japan.
The big problem with these people is that they cannot see beyond their own thoughts. Everyone has different experiences wherever they are; some feel things that others have not, while some hold different ideas about the same subject.
Sometimes I write my opinion on a certain topic, but because it differs from their experience, they start to criticize me and say that I do not know anything because I have not lived in Japan. These people need to understand that just because I said something, it does not mean that it is my final word on the subject; I fully understand that experience is relative and that each person lives a different reality.
People want to impose their opinions and realities as the only correct ones, without accepting different views. I have written several articles criticizing this attitude, and I always come back to how much experience varies from person to person. The life of a factory worker is very different from that of a university graduate working in an office.
The same tension appears in articles that take opposite sides. I have written an article praising Japan, and some readers disagreed and criticized the country. I wrote another article discussing the negative side of living in Japan, and again readers disagreed and praised it. It is always like this; people rarely reach a middle ground.
Nobody has a monopoly on knowledge
Someone who researches and writes about Japanese culture has a much greater and more diverse understanding of any subject related to the area they research. Not because they are smarter or more experienced, but because their research brings them into contact with a range of opinions on the subject.
A wise person listens to advice, regardless of the age or position of the other person. A smart person does not humiliate others, is not selfish, and tolerates many things. The common man speaks, the wise man listens, the fool argues. If you want to correct someone, no problem, but you should never act as if you know more than the other person or belittle what they know.
No student knows more than the teacher about the history or geography of a country just because the student has lived there. Of course, a person may have lived in Japan and truly understand much more about it than I or others do, but the fact is that anyone can have knowledge about a certain subject; you just have to pursue it. You do not even need a degree or a doctorate in the subject.
What a stay in Japan adds to your view
A stay in Japan can sharpen your eye for details: how people talk to each other, how daily life is organized, which rules operate in the background. It remains one route among many. Reading, films, conversations with Japanese people and Japanese history books can build a solid picture from a distance.
What matters is whether someone is willing to ask questions and reconsider their own view. That habit does not depend on a passport stamp or a residence card.






Community
Comments
0 comments
There are no published comments in this language yet.
Send comment